Flashback, anyone?
Three years back KCC scribe Dwight Sutherland saddled up to put former Star staffer Steve Kraske in his place for suggesting Kansas City take Country Club Plaza developer J.C. Nichols name off the iconic fountain just east of the Plaza.
Well, what goes around comes around, right?
In the interest of breathing a less breathless opinion into the mix, I’m reposting Sutherland’s screed.
And leave us not repeat the mistake of renaming the Paseo sans a public vote.
So here we go…
Sutherland: The Hypocrisy of Steve Kraske & The Kansas City Star
In fact, the surest way to establish one’s street cred with other members of the liberal/left is to attack the legitimacy of our country’s traditions and institutions.
This started well over 100 years ago, with the publication in 1913 of Charles Beard’s “An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States.”
According to Professor Beard, our constitution was the result of a secret plan by a well born elite to protect its power and wealth, particularly the wealth embodied in chattel slavery.
Like most leftist critiques, its value was that it discredited the very founding of the country. The American project was immoral “ab initio,” i.e. it was illegitimate from the first act. More recently, this argument has been expanded to include not just the founders, but the discoverer of America.
For at the last 30 years, history textbooks have depicted Christopher Columbus as a genocidal monster. Is it any wonder the local newspaper reported the vandalizing of his statue in various cities across the country?
Two months ago the Kansas City Star ran an opinion piece by freelance opinion columnist Steve Kraske reflecting an application of this mentality to local history.
Kraske’s June 16th piece demonstrated that the national mania for erasing the historical monuments to people who do not meet current standards of political correctness had reached Kansas City (“Everything’s up to date . . . etc.”)
Kraske argued that the J.C. Nichols Fountain on the Country Club Plaza should be renamed. He reasoned that the eponymous Jesse Clyde Nichols showed himself as a vicious racist by using racially restrictive covenants in deeds conveying ownership of homes in J.C. Nichols Company developments.
While Kraske conceded that most other developers at the time used similar exclusionary language, he said Nichols’ use was particularly effective and he should bear a large share of the blame for the resulting racial segregation in Kansas City.
This of course justified taking Nichol’s name off one if our city’s most iconic landmarks. (Which Nichols paid for, by the way!)
There are so many arguments against this position it’s hard to know where to begin.