October 19, 2018
Colleen Nelson
Editorial Page Editor, K.C. Star
1601 McGee
Kansas City, MO 64108
Re: Star Editorial Board
Dear Ms. Nelson:
I have been a reader of the Star for over 50 years. With my lifelong interest in politics, I recall having my parents send the paper to me at summer camp in 1968. I would read the paper by the light of a campfire to follow that years’ cliff hanger presidential election. As an adult active in politics, I’ve tried to maintain a cordial relationship with people who write for your paper, even when I knew they disagreed with me politically.
Over time, however, I have been forced to conclude: A) that I have been blacklisted by the paper and that no one on the paper’s staff will allow my views to be heard and, 2) that the paper has tried to hurt my reputation and standing in the community in retaliation for daring to criticize the Star’s biased political coverage.
Despite the many changes in ownership and management over the years, there is a deeply rooted institutional memory at the paper which is expressed through hostility towards me and other local conservatives.
For example, in 1998 a legal client of my firm (Lathrop & Gage) invited me to attend an Ozarks folk festival. I went to Carthage, Missouri where it was held, had lunch, picked up a check for fees, and came home. Imagine my surprise when the next day there was a front page article in the Star, describing the event as a gathering of white supremacists, with me prominently identified as one of the attendees. (This characterization of the festival, before it occurred, came from the left-wing Southern Poverty Law Center, located 700 miles away in Alabama.) The article by Judy Thomas is enclosed (Exhibit A), as is my letter in response (Exhibit B).
I think my response was measured in tone and my criticisms well-reasoned. The Star’s reaction was to call my law firm, which also represented the Star, and to try to use their influence with the firm to get me fired.
A friend of mine had a chance encounter with Ms. Thomas during this same time period. When he told her that I was upset with their reporting, Ms. Thomas told him that she hoped her article had destroyed any future I had in politics. I also received a taunting, anonymous, message about her article at my office, which our law firm in-house investigator determined was sent from Ms. Thomas’s residence via fax. I don’t think these actions reflected responsible journalistic practices.
Over the next 15 years I wrote a number of letters to the editor on a variety of subjects. I also contacted individuals on the Star staff about issues I had with the paper’s news coverage.
The letters I meant for publications I carefully edited for length and clarity. I also tried to make them cover a variety of topics. Despite my efforts, none have been published since 2001. At the “Meet The Star Editorial Board” forum, Public Editor Derek Donovan said this should not be surprising, since only one out of 20 or 30 letters ever gets published.
This is an interesting figure since your sister McClatchy paper, the Belleville News Democrat, published in one year 29 letters by James Hodgkinson, the Bernie Bro. who shot Congressman Steve Scalise and four of his staff at a Congressional baseball team practice last year. Are we to believe that Hodgkinson must have submitted between 600 and 900 letters to the Belleville paper in a year to have almost 30 published?
My complaints about biased coverage and other unethical behavior by Star journalists were brushed aside or ignored altogether. When I pointed out what I thought were clear instances of political bias to Derek Donovan, he said absent conclusive proof of my allegations (i.e. a videotape or audio tape) the Star was under no obligation to investigate them. (See e-mails attached as Exhibits C,D,&E) Continue reading →